Skip to main content Skip to footer content

Brake Pad Replacement in Menasha, WI

From brake pad replacement to full brake overhauls, our ASE-certified technicians provide brake repair services to keep your vehicle stopping smoothly in Menasha, WI.

Monday - Friday 7:00am - 6:00pm
Schedule Appointment
Google Icon
4.7 rating | 325+ reviews

Schedule Your Appointment


Google Icon
4.7 rating | 325+ reviews

Why Menasha Drivers Trust Matthews Tire for Brake Pad Replacement

At Matthews Tire, we keep you rolling. Whether you're commuting through Menasha, tackling Wisconsin’s winter roads or planning a road trip, your brakes need to be in top shape. That’s why we’re proud to be your trusted auto repair shop in Menasha, WI.

Drivers in Menasha, Appleton, Waupaca, Fond du Lac and Green Bay have trusted us for decades for brake repairs, maintenance and auto care because of our experience in the region. Our ASE-certified technicians use dealer-level equipment to diagnose and fix brake issues, ensuring your vehicle stops smoothly and safely.

Convenient Location in Menasha:

1690 Appleton Rd., Menasha, WI 54952 Call: 920-727-9901

Need a ride while we service your brakes? We’ve got you covered!

Schedule an Appointment

Providing top-quality, high-value car maintenance and auto repair services in Appleton, Menasha, Waupaca, Fond du Lac and Green Bay.

Schedule Appointment
Tire line up on a rack

Customer Testimonials

Hear from our many satisfied customers in Northeast Wisconsin. Learn why so many drivers trust their vehicles, tires and safety on the road with Matthews Tire.

The folks at MT in Menasha continue to be friendly, timely, and fair-priced on their service of my vehicles. Took my van in for an oil change and tire rotation at 8am. Knew there were some brake issues in the back and a steering issue in the front. They got me a quote and a loaner car, I was able to go about my day, and had the car back by 2pm. They’ll take great care of you and your vehicle!

— Josh Golackson

Menasha, WI
Google Icon
5.0 star rating

I had an emergency during extremely bad weather when one of my brake hoses ruptured. These guys got me in and fixed up faster than I would have thought. The price was very competitive. The staff was very helpful and friendly. I had never gone to this place before, and only went because it was so close I could get there with bad brakes, but I was very happy and I will definitely be going back for my car needs.

— Lady Taransula

Menasha, WI
Google Icon
5.0 star rating

Short notice 4 brake replacement that they didn't have the parts in house for and I still got my car back the same day!

— Hailey Binder

Menasha, WI
Google Icon
5.0 star rating

Impressed by the customer service and integrity. Methodical approach to diagnosing my issue with trailer brakes. Quick and prompt.

— Richard Krause

Menasha, WI
Google Icon
5.0 star rating

Reliable service as usual! Going back next week for rear brake calipers, rotors, and pads for my Jeep.

— Larry Darling

Menasha, WI
Google Icon
5.0 star rating

Matthews Tire is always very helpful when I have tire issues. They recently helped me with a repair that another company didn’t correctly do the first time. They also fit me in on a tight timeframe and really helped me out!

— Tammy Huza

Menasha, WI
Google Icon
5.0 star rating

I got an oil change and my windshield replaced! Anytime I come here the service is always amazing and the guys always do an amazing job!

— Skylea Ott

Menasha, WI
Google Icon
5.0 star rating

I say this every time I go to Matthews Tire... They are actually amazing. Always fit me in, and are always fair. Love this place!

— Jack Schneider

Menasha, WI
Google Icon
5.0 star rating

Read more testimonials and hear in-depth customer feedback on the customer stories page.

Customer Stories

How Often Should You Change Brake Pads?

Brake pads should generally be replaced every 30,000 to 70,000 miles, depending on driving habits, road conditions and brake pad material. Frequent city driving, stop-and-go traffic and heavy braking cause pads to wear out faster, while highway driving allows them to last longer.

High-performance or ceramic pads may also have different lifespans. Regularly inspect your brake pads and replace them if they are thinner than 3mm (about 1/8 inch), producing squealing noises, or causing reduced braking performance. Staying proactive with brake maintenance ensures optimal safety and performance.

Schedule Your Brake Repair
Automotive technician replacing brakes on vehicle

How Do You Know if Brake Pads Need Replacing?

Brake pads need replacing if you hear persistent squealing, grinding, or squeaking noises, experience reduced braking performance, or see the brake warning light (if equipped). Visual signs include brake pads worn to 3-4 mm (about 1/8 inch) or less.

Additional indicators include a longer stopping distance, a spongy or unresponsive brake pedal and a pulsating sensation when braking, which may suggest uneven pad wear or rotor issues. Regular inspections and timely replacements help maintain braking efficiency and prevent potential brake failure.

new brake pads and rotors on vehicle

How Do You Tell if You Need Brake Pads or Rotors?

You need new brake pads if you hear squealing, experience reduced braking or see pad thickness below 3-4 mm (about 1/8 inch). Uneven or worn rotors cause vibrations, a pulsating brake pedal or scoring marks on the rotor surface. If braking feels rough or inconsistent, inspect both pads and rotors for wear.

new brake pads and rotors sitting on table

Can You Replace Brake Pads Without Replacing the Rotors?

Brake pads can be replaced without replacing the rotors if the rotors are in good condition. The rotors should be smooth, free of deep grooves, cracks or excessive scoring, and within the manufacturer’s minimum thickness specification.

If rotors show uneven wear, warping (causing vibration when braking), or excessive wear, they should be resurfaced (if thickness allows) or replaced to ensure optimal braking performance. Always inspect the rotors during a brake pad replacement to avoid premature pad wear or reduced stopping power.

new brake pads being installed on vehicle

Why Choose Our Brake Pad Replacement Service in Menasha, WI?

At Matthews Tire, we’re more than just an auto shop—we’re part of the Menasha community. Here’s why drivers trust us for brake pad replacements, routine maintenance, and more in Menasha, WI.

  • Expert Technicians: With automotive experience in Northeast Wisconsin since 1952, our team services all makes and models, from family sedans to performance vehicles.
  • Transparent Pricing: No hidden fees—just clear, honest estimates before we start work.
  • State-of-the-Art Equipment: We use modern diagnostic tools to ensure precise brake pad replacements for your optimal safety.
  • Local Convenience: With locations throughout Northeast Wisconsin, our technicians understand the unique driving conditions in our region.

Whether it’s routine brake pad maintenance or addressing squeaky brakes, we treat every vehicle with care. At Matthews Tire, we’ve been keeping Menasha drivers safe on the road since 1989 and in Northeast Wisconsin for over 70 years.

Schedule Your Brake Repair
new brake pads and rotors on vehicle raised on lift

Experience Auto Excellence

Never settle for subpar, overpriced auto services ever again! The ASE-certified technicians at Matthews Tire are here to bring you world-class service, dealer-level auto parts and unbeatable value on every service.

From tire installations, oil changes and alignments to full-service brake repairs, engine overhauls and more, we’ll keep you rolling.

Schedule Appointment
Happy family driving in a car together