The Matthew's Difference

Bring your car to the experts you can trust at Matthews Tire. From high-quality tires, rotations and alignments to same-day oil changes, brake replacements and more, we’re here to keep you rolling—no excuses guaranteed.

Stop in today to experience our impeccable service and nationwide product warranties!

Services_Wheel-Balance-Icon

Complete Automotive Services

Along with offering a full selection of quality tire brands, Matthews provides comprehensive automotive services, from routine maintenance to complex diagnostics and engine repairs.

Services_Flat-Repair-Icon

Largest Tire Inventory

Matthews carries all major tire brands to give you the best options for performance, value, and safety.

Cell Phone Icon Matthews

Upgraded Convenience for Every Driver

Book your service or tire appointment online and get a free digital report sent straight to your phone, helping you understand your car’s condition with confidence.

Services_Customer-Icon

Satisfied Customers

Matthews Tire Express provides expert service and top tire brands. With a 4.8-star customer rating, we’re dedicated to quality and your confidence on the road.

Services_Pin-Icon

Convenient Locations

Matthews proudly serves Northeast Wisconsin with convenient locations. With a shop near you, expert tire and auto service is just a call or click away.

Services_Service-Icon

Trusted, Certified ASE Technicians

Whatever you drive and whatever your car needs, trust Matthews' expert ASE‑certified technicians to get the job done right!

Shop Tires Online

Step 1:
Pick a Location

Step 2:
Browse and Buy

Step 3:
Make an Appointment

Our Satisfied Customers

Don't just take our word for it: with a 4.8-star customer rating, we’re dedicated to quality and your confidence on the road.

When I brought my car in for new tires and an alignment, they brought additional repair needs to my attention and worked hard to complete all of the work that day! I wouldn’t hesitate to go back to Matthews for my future repair needs.

As a single mom with a tight budget who also doesn’t want to spare on safety, Matthews Tire has been my go-to mechanic for years. They are priced fairly and do prompt and quality work, and they are all great communicators. I never question their input or recommendations and they’ve earned two generations of customers with my teen drivers.

The service and attitude are amazing at Matthews Tire! I’ve had a couple of friends call other local auto shops for assistance only to be met with cold service and unbudging, overpriced service quotes. In both cases, the team at Matthews Tire were immediately engaged in helpful and creative problem solving to come up with great solutions and service in record time!