Learn more about the benefits of working with ASE-certified technicians.

Trusted Oil Change in Menasha, WI

Your Car Deserves More Than a 10-Minute Oil Change

When it’s time for an oil change in Menasha, trust an auto repair shop that puts quality and care first. Our locally operated shop provides quick, dependable care from ASE-certified technicians, using premium oil, high-grade filters and professional tools. This goes beyond basic maintenance. It’s critical protection for your engine that keeps your vehicle performing reliably and your schedule stress-free.

Family-owned, proudly serving Northeast Wisconsin since 1952
Upfront quotes with no hidden fees or surprises
Thousands of happy customers and counting

Schedule Your Oil Change Today

4.6 average rating | 2230+ reviews

A+ Rating

Schedule Your Appointment

Find Our Auto Repair Shop Near You in Menasha, WI

We’re located on Appleton Rd just off Hwy 10, near spots like the Barlow Planetarium, restaurants, and other local attractions.

We’re open Monday – Friday from 7:00am to 6:00pm

Need directions? Call us at 920-727-9901. We’ll be happy to help you find us.

Get Directions

Customer Testimonials

Hear from our many satisfied customers in Northeast Wisconsin. Learn why so many drivers trust their vehicles, tires and safety on the road with Matthews Tire.

Matthews Tire is a fantastic place to get your car fixed. I always feel confident that they will do a good job. They are friendly and considerate and do what they can to make your car run well.

— Cammy Draheim

Menasha, WI

5.0 star rating

I have been a customer for a long time and I have received great service every time I have been there. I would recommend them highly.

— Bob Smith

Menasha, WI

5.0 star rating

Li was great and explained everything thoroughly, Matthews Tire in Menasha was amazing and took us through every step.

— Cheyenne Selbach

Menasha, WI

5.0 star rating

Matthews Tire Menasha has been my service dealer for 5+ years. They are always very professional and fair with prices. In most cases they are very accommodating with getting you on the schedule and in for service quickly. Thanks Matthews!

— Michael Love

Menasha, WI

5.0 star rating

Matthews Tire in Menasha is my first choice for all maintenance on my vehicles. They go out of the way to accommodate. Extremely friendly and knowledgeable staff. I highly recommend!

— Tim Quadracci

Menasha, WI

5.0 star rating

Matthews Tire is always very helpful when I have tire issues. They recently helped me with a repair that another company didn’t correctly do the first time. They also fit me in on a tight timeframe and really helped me out!

— Tammy Huza

Menasha, WI

5.0 star rating

I got an oil change and my windshield replaced! Anytime I come here the service is always amazing and the guys always do an amazing job!

— Skylea Ott

Menasha, WI

5.0 star rating

I say this every time I go to Matthews Tire... They are actually amazing. Always fit me in, and are always fair. Love this place!

— Jack Schneider

Menasha, WI

5.0 star rating

Read more testimonials and hear in-depth customer feedback on the customer stories page.

Customer Stories

Top-Rated Oil Change Near You in Menasha, WI

Why Choose Matthews Tire for Your Next Oil Change?

Choosing the right service for your vehicle maintenance can extend the life of your vehicle and enhance its performance. Here’s why our auto repair service stands out in Menasha, WI:

Expert technicians: Our certified mechanics are trained to handle a wide range of vehicle services including conventional oil changes, synthetic oil changes in Menasha, transmission repair, brake repair, radiator flush and more.
High-quality oil options: We offer a range of top-quality oils, including synthetic, semi-synthetic, high-mileage and conventional, to best fit your vehicle’s needs and your personal preferences.
Comprehensive courtesy check: Each oil change comes with a complimentary vehicle health check to identify potential issues before they become costly car repairs.
Transparent pricing: We understand that auto maintenance can be stressful. We provide upfront pricing without any hidden fees. You know exactly what you’re paying for.
Convenient service: Book appointments at times that work for you. We offer same-day service options to get you back on the road quickly.
Customer satisfaction guarantee: We strive to provide the best customer service in Menasha, WI with a focus on customer satisfaction and vehicle care. Book your next oil change with us and experience the difference professional care makes for your vehicle.

Automotive technician replacing brakes on vehicle

5.0 star rating

“I left my previous auto shop because each time I returned for an oil change or service there were different people working there. Matthews feels like the family auto shop I can trust.”

— Joel Krueger

A Better Oil Change Experience, Start to Finish

At Matthews Tire, we know you’re not just looking for a basic oil change. You want trusted mechanics who treat your car with care, use high-quality oil and filters and respect your time. You want someone who will check your engine, not just check a box. That’s exactly what we deliver, every time.

Schedule Your Oil Change Today

Why Regular Oil Changes Matter

How Oil Changes Protect Your Engine and Save You Money

An oil change might feel like standard vehicle maintenance, but it plays an essential part in your car’s long-term health and reliability. At Matthews Tire, we help you safeguard your engine with expert, timely service that goes beyond the basics. Here’s how regular oil changes support your vehicle:

Improve gas mileage by decreasing engine friction and stress.
Prevent heat damage with fresh, smooth-flowing lubricant.
Extend engine longevity by minimizing friction and breakdown.
Reduce emissions and keep your engine running cleaner.
Catch small issues early through inspections and fluid monitoring.

Not sure whether it’s time for service? Drop in or give us a call. We’ll check for you and let you know if you’re due.

Mechanic holding a used oil filter during an oil change service in Menasha, WI.

5.0 star rating

“Excellent service! Technician carefully explained recommended maintenance issue identified during oil change. Report and pictures received via email while waiting helped me be prepared for discussing the issue.”

— Jonathan Cloud

What to Expect During Your Oil Change in Menasha, WI

Routine Maintenance That Goes Beyond the Basics

Each oil change at Matthews Tire offers more than a routine oil top-off. Our ASE-certified technicians take the time to care for your vehicle with focus, accuracy and premium-grade products. Here’s what happens during your visit:

Drain used engine oil and refill with the correct synthetic or conventional lubricant for your car.
Replace the oil filter with a dependable match suited to your vehicle.
Check and refill essential fluids like antifreeze and washer fluid.
Examine belts, hoses and your engine bay for wear, leaks or safety issues.
Assess tire pressure and add air as needed for ride comfort and efficiency.
Reset the dashboard oil reminder and verify your next service interval.

Auto technician inspecting engine components with a checklist during an oil change in Menasha, WI.

5.0 star rating

“These guys have helped me out on more than one occasion, whether it be for a simple oil change all the way up to extensive diagnostic services. They are very timely and will strive to get you back on the road as soon as possible.”

— Charlotte Wynen

Don’t Just Change Your Oil, Protect Your Investment

Whether you drive a commuter car, a family SUV or a weekend truck, keeping up with oil changes isn’t optional, it’s essential. At Matthews Tire, we make it easy to stay ahead of engine trouble with quick, professional service that puts your needs first. No high-pressure upsells. No shortcuts. Just honest, certified care that gives you confidence every time you turn the key. When you choose Matthews Tire, you make a smart move for your engine’s health and your own peace of mind.

Schedule Your Oil Change Appointment

Oil Change for the Better

Each year, Matthews Tire hosts an oil change fundraising event to support a local nonprofit making a positive impact in the community.

Visit our community page to learn more, and contact your local Matthews Tire auto shop to get dates for the next Oil Change for the Better event.

Frequently Asked Oil Change Questions

Are synthetic oils better than conventional oil?

Yes, synthetic oils offer distinct advantages over conventional motor oils. Synthetic oils are made from more refined base oils. As a result, they deliver enhanced chemical stability and performance. They are less prone to breakdown, ensuring better long-term protection for engine components. Synthetic blend or full synthetic oils excel in extreme conditions, providing superior lubrication during high-temperature operation. Synthetic oils also help oil flow rapidly in cold starts, protecting critical engine parts more effectively than conventional oils.

How does dirty oil affect my car's engine?

Dirty oil can cause major engine damage, primarily because it loses its lubrication over time. As oil circulates through the engine, it picks up debris, dust, and metal particles, which can contaminate it. This contamination causes the oil to become thicker and abrasive. Dirty oil increases wear and tear on engine components. Over time, if not changed, dirty oil can lead to sludge buildup. Sludge can block oil passages, starving the engine of necessary lubrication and cooling. This ultimately leads to engine problems such as reduced efficiency, potential engine failure, and costly car repairs. Regular oil changes are crucial to prevent these issues and keep your engine running smoothly and efficiently.

How do you know when oil needs to be changed?

You know oil needs to be changed when it appears dark and dirty, the engine makes noise or the oil change indicator light turns on. Most vehicles also require an oil change every 3,000 to 7,500 miles depending on the manufacturer’s guidelines and oil type.

How long does an oil change take?

An oil change typically takes 20 to 45 minutes, depending on your vehicle and whether additional services like filter replacement or inspections are needed. At Matthews Tire, we don’t just swap oil. We also check belts and hoses, inspect your engine bay, top off essential fluids and adjust tire pressure as needed. It’s efficient, thorough service that protects your vehicle and keeps you safely on the road.

How often should you change your oil?

Change your oil every 3,000 to 7,500 miles, depending on your vehicle’s make, model, and the type of oil used. Synthetic oils allow for longer intervals, often up to 10,000 miles. Always follow the manufacturer’s maintenance schedule for optimal engine performance.

Is it safe to delay an oil change during Menasha winters?

Delaying an oil change during Menasha winters is not safe. Winters here can be brutal, and cold weather thickens your oil. If you’re running errands in January and your oil hasn’t been changed, your engine is under extra stress. Regular changes help it run smoother in freezing temperatures.

What kind of oil do you use for cars in Menasha’s cold weather?

We recommend 5W-30 or 0W-20 full synthetic oil during Menasha’s colder months. These options flow better at low temps, which is key when your car’s parked outside in below-zero conditions, especially near the bay where wind chills drop fast.

Is it worth getting an oil change before a road trip from Menasha?

Definitely. If you’re getting ready for a long road trip, fresh oil helps your engine handle the miles. It’s even more important if the car’s been sitting or you’ve had a rough winter driving season.

How close are you to Menasha neighborhoods like Neenah, Fox Crossing or Appleton for oil changes?

We’re conveniently located in Menasha, just minutes from Neenah, Fox Crossing and Appleton. Whether you’re coming from the east via Lake Park Road or from the west through downtown Neenah or Highway 441, our shop is easy to reach. We’re also close to major routes like WIS 47 and WIS 114, making it accessible for drivers throughout the Fox Cities. With nearby landmarks like Jefferson Park, downtown Menasha, and the Fox River, you’ll have plenty of ways to stay productive or unwind while we handle your oil changes.

Experience Auto Excellence

Never settle for subpar, overpriced auto services ever again! The ASE-certified technicians at Matthews Tire are here to bring you world-class service, dealer-level auto parts and unbeatable value on every service.

From tire installations, oil changes and alignments to full-service brake repairs, engine overhauls and more, we’ll keep you rolling.

Schedule Appointment

Schedule Appointment