Skip to main content Skip to footer content

Trusted Tire Repair in Fond du Lac, WI

Get Fast, Honest Flat Tire Repair And Get Back to What Matters Most

Tire repair in Fond du Lac, WI, doesn’t have to derail your day. At Matthews Tire, we know your life doesn’t pause for a flat. Whether it’s a slow leak, sharp puncture or sudden blowout, our certified mechanics in Fond du Lac diagnose the problem and get you back on the road fast. No pressure. No guesswork.

  • Family-owned, proudly serving Northeast Wisconsin since 1952
  • Upfront quotes with no hidden fees or surprises
  • Thousands of happy customers and counting
Schedule Your Tire Repair Today
Google Icon
4.6 average rating | 2230+ reviews
A+ Rating

Schedule Your Appointment


Find Our Auto Repair Shop Near You in Fond du Lac, WI

Our Fond du Lac location is easy to find on W Johnson Street. We’re right next to Friar Tuck’s and Gino’s Italian Restaurant, with plenty of parking available behind our building. To reach the parking lot, turn off W Johnson Street onto N Seymour Street, then take a right onto Lee Court for a hassle-free arrival.

We’re open Monday – Friday from 7:00am to 6:00pm

Need directions? Call us at 920-921-6261. We’ll be happy to help you find us.

Get Directions
Tire line up on a rack

Customer Testimonials

Hear from our many satisfied customers in Northeast Wisconsin. Learn why so many drivers trust their vehicles, tires and safety on the road with Matthews Tire.

I found myself with a dead car battery late in the afternoon! Called Matthews Tire and they told me to bring the car in immediately, which I did! Fifteen minutes later my battery was installed! The reception area where I waited was very clean and inviting. Terrific "service with a smile" from the two gentlemen that were at the reception desk!

— Gail Kraig

Fond du Lac, WI
Google Icon
5.0 star rating

Always bring my car here for everything... never have any complaints. Excellent and fast service. Everyone there is very pleasant. Just brought my car in with a flat tire and they gave me a new tire in just a few minutes. I was very relieved that they fixed it so fast.

— Janet Reehl Shaw

Fond du Lac, WI
Google Icon
5.0 star rating

I always have my maintenance done on my car at Matthews Tire in Fond du Lac. Todd Steffes is top notch. He is very friendly and knowledgeable. The entire staff are very nice and professional. They always accommodate you with whatever you need, whether it is a ride to and from work or a loaner vehicle for the day. Great customer service!

— Susie Ballantyne

Fond du Lac, WI
Google Icon
5.0 star rating

Matthews Tires has been servicing my cars for 30 years. I am a repeat customer because Todd has always been fair and honest in his dealings with me. Quality work, honest and fair pricing and an always pleasant and friendly staff does it for me.

— Dolly Miller-Brennan

Fond du Lac, WI
Google Icon
5.0 star rating

The staff at Matthews Tire is very friendly and knowledgeable. This is a place you can trust to do quality work and they stand behind this. Their prices are average but you definitely get what you pay for!! I will continue to use them for all my repair needs!!

— Louis Ferren

Fond du Lac, WI
Google Icon
5.0 star rating

Always a great experience at Matthews Tire in Fond du Lac. Staff is accommodating with appointment times, knowledgeable in keeping my vehicle on time for scheduled maintenance and access to the loaner vehicle when necessary is always appreciated!

— Doug Olig

Fond du Lac, WI
Google Icon
5.0 star rating

I called them at about 8 am... I needed my tire replaced ASAP. They worked me into the schedule for that day, and per my last minute request, replaced all 4 tires! My car was ready by mid afternoon! Thanks guys! Great Job!

— Debbie Aird

Fond du Lac, WI
Google Icon
5.0 star rating

Read more testimonials and hear in-depth customer feedback on the customer stories page.

Customer Stories

Fond du Lac Tire Repair Services

Unsure if Your Tire Is Still Safe? Catch the Early Warning Signs and Get Ahead of Costly Repairs.

Common signs that your tires need repair or replacement include visible damage like cracks, bulges or embedded objects, low tire tread, low tire pressure and unusual vibrations or noises while driving. Additionally, a tire pressure monitoring system (TPMS) alert or the presence of tread wear indicators can signal tire issues. Here’s a more detailed breakdown of what to look out for:

  • Bulges or blisters: These indicate internal damage and a potential blowout risk.
  • Cracks or cuts: Cracks, especially in the sidewall, can signal dry rot or damage from UV exposure or chemicals.
  • Embedded objects: Objects like nails or screws lodged in the tire can cause leaks or further damage.
  • TPMS light is on: The Tire Pressure Monitoring System light on your dashboard indicates low pressure in one or more tires.
  • Tire looks flat: A visibly low tire or a tire that feels soft or underinflated is a clear sign of a problem.

If you’re hearing unusual noises, feeling vibrations or topping off air more than usual, don’t ignore it. Bring your vehicle in for a quick inspection. We’ll let you know if the tire can be safely repaired or if replacement is the smarter call.

Technician using power tool to rotate car tires in professional shop in Fond du Lac, WI.
Google Icon
5.0 star rating

“All info was clearly explained and the final option was cost effective. No upsell or pressure to spend more than needed. Their advice was honest, cost-effective and trustworthy.”

— Katie Byrum

Don’t Let a Flat Tire Slow You Down

At Matthews Tire, we make tire repair in Fond du Lac, WI, simple and straightforward. As a trusted local auto repair shop, we pride ourselves on fixing flats fast. No guesswork. No pressure. Just honest service that gets you moving again. Whether it’s your daily driver or your family vehicle, we’ve got you covered.

Book Your Tire Repair Today

What to Expect During Your Tire Repair in Fond du Lac, WI

No Unnecessary Replacements. Just Safe, Efficient Repair.

Worried about costly repairs? When you come to Matthews Tire for tire repair in Fond du Lac, here’s what you can expect:

  • Expert diagnosis: Our ASE-certified techs inspect your tire inside and out, checking tread, sidewalls, valves, rims and more.
  • Transparent advice: If we can repair it safely, we will. If the damage is outside repair guidelines (e.g., sidewall tears or large punctures), we’ll explain your options with zero pressure.
  • Fast, certified service: We use industry-standard patch and plug techniques for lasting durability. A plug is inserted through the puncture and a patch is applied to the inside of the tire to create a seal. Most flat repairs are done in under an hour.
  • Peace of mind: We’ll reinstall your tire on the rim and inflate to the proper pressure. We’ll rebalance your wheel, check the tire for leaks and make sure everything’s ready for safe driving.

Need a ride? We offer shuttle service or loaner vehicles for longer repairs.

Auto mechanic rotating front tire on service van during fleet maintenance in Fond du Lac, WI.
Google Icon
5.0 star rating

“I brought my vehicle in for squeaky brakes and instead of fixing it and charging me, they actually told me that it didn't need repair! Instead of getting a few hundred bucks, they got a customer for life.”

— Paul Wisneski

Top-Rated Tire Repair in Fond du Lac, WI

Why Fond du Lac Drivers Trust Matthews Tire for Tire Repair

We’re not just a local repair shop. We’re part of the Fond du Lac community. For over 70 years, Matthews Tire has helped you stay safe and get more life out of your tires. When you need peace of mind and high-quality tire repair services, here’s why you can count on us:

  • ASE-certified technicians: With years of expertise and rigorous training, our team ensures every service we provide meets the highest standards. From brake repair and oil changes to tire rotations in Fond du Lac and tire balancing, we keep you rolling!
  • Local expertise, national-quality care: With over 70 years of serving the Fox Valley, our ASE-certified technicians bring both the small-town honesty and dealer-level professionalism you expect.
  • Family-friendly service: We proudly serve commuters, families and DIY car owners. We offer clean waiting areas, transparent communication and loaner options if needed. We make car care easy.
  • No excuses guaranteed: If something didn’t go as you expected, we will do everything to make it right.

At Matthews Tire, we help Fond du Lac drivers stay safe, save money and get back on the road with confidence.

Friendly staff member assisting customers at Matthews Tire front desk in Fond du Lac, WI.
Google Icon
5.0 star rating

“I have been doing business here for over 20 years. I have purchased many sets of tires, had brake work and alignments done, and I am sure many other things... What great service! Hats off to Dave and the rest of the Matthews crew!”

— Rick Volkman

Real Tire Repairs. Real Peace of Mind.

Putting off a repair might feel harmless. Until it isn’t. Whether it’s a slow leak, sidewall crack or an embedded nail or screw, if we can repair it safely, we will. At Matthews Tire, we give you back your confidence behind the wheel. Book a tire repair appointment and know for sure if your tire is safe to drive on.

Book a Tire Repair Appointment

Frequently Asked Tire Repair Questions

How long does a tire repair take at your Fond du Lac shop?

A tire repair typically takes 20 to 30 minutes at a professional shop. The process includes removing the tire, inspecting the damage, applying a patch or plug and remounting the tire. Time may increase if additional repairs are needed.

We’re right off Johnson Street, so it’s easy to drop your vehicle off and grab lunch at Friar Tuck’s, Gino’s Italian Restaurant or Riviera Maya Mexican Bar & Grill. We’re also close enough to grab some coffee downtown at Lavish Coffee, Wonder or Just Love Coffee Cafe.

How much does it cost to repair a tire?
The average cost to repair a tire in 2025 ranges from about $20 to $50, but some specialized fixes can cost $100 or more. Prices depend on the type of damage and whether the tire needs a patch or plug.
What’s the difference between a tire patch and a tire plug?
A patch seals the puncture from the inside of the tire by bonding a rubber piece to the inner liner, while a plug fills the hole from the outside with a rubber stem inserted into the tread. For the most reliable repair, we’ll often use a combination of a patch and plug, which seals both the inside and the outside channel.
What tire damage cannot be repaired?
According to the Tire Industry Association guidelines, tires should not be repaired if they have punctures in the sidewall, large cuts or gashes, tread separation, or bead damage. Repairs are also unsafe if the puncture exceeds 1/4 inch (6 mm) in diameter or if there are multiple punctures close together, as these conditions compromise the tire’s structural integrity.
How long does a tire repair last?
A tire repair from a professional auto repair shop can last for up to 7 to 10 years, matching the tire’s remaining lifespan if done correctly. Longevity depends on proper patching, the location of damage and tire maintenance. Repairs on sidewalls or large punctures are unsafe and should not be driven on.
Can a tire with a nail or screw in it be repaired?
You can repair a tire with a nail in it if the puncture is in the tread and less than 1/4 inch (6 mm) in diameter. A professional should remove the nail, inspect the tire and apply a plug-patch from the inside. Damage to sidewalls or shoulders cannot be safely repaired.
How close are you to Fond du Lac neighborhoods like North Fond du Lac or Taycheedah for tire repair?
We’re conveniently located in Fond du Lac, just minutes from North Fond du Lac, Taycheedah and the surrounding areas. Whether you’re coming from the east side near Lake Winnebago and Highway 151 or the west side along Highway 41, getting here is simple. Our Johnson Street location is easy to find and centrally located. It’s also near Highway 41, making it convenient for drivers from Woodhull, Eldorado, Van Dyne and Oakfield. With nearby landmarks like Lakeside Park, you’ll have no trouble finding something to do while your vehicle is in the shop. You can take care of errands or enjoy some local entertainment while we handle your tire repair.

Experience Auto Excellence

Never settle for subpar, overpriced auto services ever again! The ASE-certified technicians at Matthews Tire are here to bring you world-class service, dealer-level auto parts and unbeatable value on every service.

From tire installations, oil changes and alignments to full-service brake repairs, engine overhauls and more, we’ll keep you rolling.

Schedule Appointment
Happy family driving in a car together
Schedule Appointment