Expert Transmission Repair in Appleton, WI
Don’t Let a Bad Transmission Leave You Stranded
If your car is slipping gears, making strange noises or just not driving right, don’t wait. Our ASE-certified mechanics in Appleton specialize in honest, high-quality transmission repair that keeps you safely on the road. Whether you need diagnostics, a rebuild or a full replacement, we’ll explain your options clearly and treat your car like it’s our own.
- Transparent pricing and trusted local service
- Fast turnaround times without sacrificing quality
- Family-owned and operated in Appleton since 1952
Find Our Auto Repair Shop Near You in Appleton West
We’re conveniently located on College Avenue, between North Lynndale Drive and North Bluemound Drive. We're only minutes from the Fox River Mall and downtown Appleton. Whether you're heading to work or running errands, our Appleton auto repair shop is easy to get to and even easier to work with.
If you're coming from out of town or traveling on Highway 41, we're located just one mile off the main highway, making us a quick stop for preventive maintenance or a routine oil change.
Get DirectionsFind Our Auto Repair Shop Near You in Appleton East
We're located right off Highway 441 by the Marcus Valley Grand Cinema and the Quality Inn & Suites. This location makes for an easy stop for drivers from Darboy and surrounding neighborhoods.
Coming from out of town or traveling on Highway 441? We’re located just off the highway, with plenty of shopping, dining and entertainment options nearby. It's perfect if you’d rather stay busy while we take care of your vehicle’s oil change or maintenance.
Get Directions
Customer Testimonials
Hear from our many satisfied customers in Northeast Wisconsin. Learn why so many drivers trust their vehicles, tires and safety on the road with Matthews Tire.
Read more testimonials and hear in-depth customer feedback on the customer stories page.
Customer StoriesTop-Rated Transmission Repair in Appleton, WI
Why Choose Our Transmission Repair Shop in Appleton, WI?
We’re more than a repair shop, we’re part of the Appleton community. Here’s why locals trust us for transmission repairs, windshield repairs, brake repairs and more in Appleton, WI.
- Expert technicians: With automotive experience since 1952, we can handle all makes and models, from vintage cars to luxury SUVs.
- Transparent pricing: No hidden fees, just clear, honest estimates.
- State-of-the-art tools: Modern diagnostic equipment ensures we fix it right the first time.
- Local convenience: With locations across Northeast Wisconsin, we understand the unique needs of Wisconsin drivers.
Whether it’s a quick fluid change or a full rebuild, we treat every vehicle with care. At Matthews Tire, we’re proud to deliver the same exceptional service that’s kept Appleton drivers rolling for over 70 years.
“I have been a customer for almost 20 years and wouldn't go anywhere else. Matthews Tire is phenomenal.”
— Monica Goodman
Transmission Trouble? We’ll Get You Back on the Road
At Matthews Tire, we know transmission issues can be stressful. That’s why we deliver honest answers, expert repairs and fast turnaround, so you can get back to your routine with confidence. Whether you need diagnostics, a fluid service or a full rebuild, we’ve got you covered. Our ASE-certified team delivers transparent pricing and trusted local care every step of the way.
Appleton Transmission Repair
What Are the Signs That Your Transmission Needs Repair?
Spotting transmission trouble early can save you time, money and stress. If something feels off with your vehicle, here are the most common signs to watch for:
- Difficulty shifting gears: Hesitation or refusal when changing gears.
- Strange noises: Grinding, clunking or whining often point to transmission problems.
- Slipping gears: Your vehicle changes gears unexpectedly or can’t stay in gear.
- Delayed engagement: A noticeable lag when shifting from park to drive or reverse.
- Fluid leaks: Look for red or sweet-smelling liquid under your vehicle.
- Burning smell: This could mean your transmission is overheating.
These issues can happen to anyone and catching them early is the smartest way to avoid breakdowns and expensive repairs. Our ASE-certified technicians have helped thousands of Appleton drivers get back on the road with confidence.
“Awesome service and keeping my cars running for more the 30 years”
— Nathan Kister
Appleton Transmission Shop
Common Signs and Issues We Fix Every Day
Not sure what’s wrong with your transmission? Don’t worry, most issues start with small signs. Here are some of the most common problems we see (and fix) in our Appleton shop:
- Leaking or low transmission fluid: You might notice red fluid under your car or gear slipping.
- Grinding or hard shifting: Often caused by worn gears or internal damage.
- Delayed or erratic shifting: This can point to a sensor or solenoid issue in automatic vehicles.
- Clutch problems in manuals: If your clutch feels sticky or soft, it may be worn out.
Whatever the issue, our ASE-certified technicians use advanced diagnostics and years of experience to pinpoint the problem and make lasting repairs. You don’t have to guess, we’ll explain everything clearly before we start any work.
“I have been a customer here since 1995. They sell a huge selection of great tires and do a lot of service work on all kinds of cars and trucks.”
— Thomas Whittenberger
Trusted by Appleton Drivers for Over 70 Years
When it comes to transmission repair, Appleton drivers choose Matthews Tire for one reason: peace of mind. From accurate diagnostics to high-quality repairs and fair pricing, our ASE-certified team is here to get you back on the road, with confidence. Schedule today and see why generations of Appleton families trust our name.
Frequently Asked Transmission Repair Questions
What is the most common cause of transmission failure?
The leading cause of transmission failure is overheating, often due to:
- Low or contaminated fluid: inadequate lubrication and cooling.
- Neglected maintenance: failing to perform regular fluid changes and inspections.
Regular maintenance is essential to prevent such issues.
Can a damaged transmission be repaired?
Is it cheaper to repair or replace a transmission?
The cost-effectiveness of repairing versus replacing a transmission depends on the extent of the damage:
- Minor Issues: Addressing small problems early can often be resolved with repairs, which are generally less expensive.
- Major Damage: Severe issues may necessitate a complete replacement, which can be more costly.
How long will a repaired transmission last?
Is it worth fixing a transmission in an older car?
Deciding whether to repair a transmission in an older vehicle involves considering the following:
- Vehicle’s overall condition: Assessing the state of other major components.
- Repair costs vs. vehicle value: Comparing the repair expenses to the car’s market value.
Consulting with a trusted mechanic can help determine the most cost-effective approach.
Is a rebuilt transmission as good as new?
How close are you to Appleton neighborhoods like Grand Chute or Kimberly for transmission repair?
Do cold Appleton winters cause transmission problems?
Is it okay to keep driving in Appleton with a slipping transmission?
Is your shop close to public transportation if I leave my car for transmission repair?
Experience Auto Excellence
Never settle for subpar, overpriced auto services ever again! The ASE-certified technicians at Matthews Tire are here to bring you world-class service, dealer-level auto parts and unbeatable value on every service.
From tire installations, oil changes and alignments to full-service brake repairs, engine overhauls and more, we’ll keep you rolling.
Schedule Appointment
