Skip to main content Skip to footer content

Expert Brake Pad Replacement in Menasha, WI

Don’t Risk Your Safety, Replace Your Brake Pads Before It’s Too Late

When you need brake pad service, count on a local Menasha auto repair shop that puts safety and precision first. If your brakes are squealing, vibrating or not performing like they should, don’t delay. At Matthews Tire, our ASE-certified technicians thoroughly inspect your entire brake system and install reliable pads, rotors and hardware designed for smooth, confident stopping power.

  • ASE-certified technicians
  • Family-owned and trusted by Wisconsin drivers since 1952
  • Quality brake parts with professional installation
Schedule Your Brake Repair Today
Google Icon
4.6 average rating | 2230+ reviews
A+ Rating

Schedule Your Appointment


Find Our Auto Repair Shop Near You in Menasha, WI

We’re located on Appleton Rd., just off Hwy 10, with nearby spots like the Barlow Planetarium, restaurants, and other local attractions.

We’re open Monday – Friday from 7:00am to 6:00pm

Need directions? Call us at 920-727-9901. We’ll be happy to help you find us.

Get Directions
Tire line up on a rack

Customer Testimonials

Hear from our many satisfied customers in Northeast Wisconsin. Learn why so many drivers trust their vehicles, tires and safety on the road with Matthews Tire.

The folks at Matthews Tire in Menasha continue to be friendly, timely, and fair-priced on their service of my vehicles. Took my van in for an oil change and tire rotation at 8am. Knew there were some brake issues in the back and a steering issue in the front. They got me a quote and a loaner car, I was able to go about my day, and had the car back by 2pm. They’ll take great care of you and your vehicle!

— Josh Golackson

Menasha, WI
Google Icon
5.0 star rating

I had an emergency during extremely bad weather when one of my brake hoses ruptured. These guys got me in and fixed up faster than I would have thought. The price was very competitive. The staff was very helpful and friendly. I had never gone to this place before, and only went because it was so close I could get there with bad brakes, but I was very happy and I will definitely be going back for my car needs.

— Lady Taransula

Menasha, WI
Google Icon
5.0 star rating

Short notice 4 brake replacement that they didn't have the parts in house for and I still got my car back the same day!

— Hailey Binder

Menasha, WI
Google Icon
5.0 star rating

Impressed by the customer service and integrity. Methodical approach to diagnosing my issue with trailer brakes. Quick and prompt.

— Richard Krause

Menasha, WI
Google Icon
5.0 star rating

Reliable service as usual! Going back next week for rear brake calipers, rotors, and pads for my Jeep.

— Larry Darling

Menasha, WI
Google Icon
5.0 star rating

Matthews Tire is always very helpful when I have tire issues. They recently helped me with a repair that another company didn’t correctly do the first time. They also fit me in on a tight timeframe and really helped me out!

— Tammy Huza

Menasha, WI
Google Icon
5.0 star rating

I got an oil change and my windshield replaced! Anytime I come here the service is always amazing and the guys always do an amazing job!

— Skylea Ott

Menasha, WI
Google Icon
5.0 star rating

I say this every time I go to Matthews Tire... They are actually amazing. Always fit me in, and are always fair. Love this place!

— Jack Schneider

Menasha, WI
Google Icon
5.0 star rating

Read more testimonials and hear in-depth customer feedback on the customer stories page.

Customer Stories

Trusted Brake Pad Replacement in Menasha, WI

Why Menasha Drivers Choose Matthews Tire for Brake Repairs

We’re more than a local brake shop, we’re part of the Menasha community. Here’s why drivers here rely on us for brake pad replacement, complete repairs and routine maintenance across Menasha, WI.

  • Certified Technicians: Our ASE-certified team has decades of experience with all makes and models, from compact cars to family-size SUVs.
  • Honest Estimates: You’ll always receive straightforward quotes and clear details, no upsells or pressure tactics.
  • Cutting-Edge Tools: We use advanced diagnostics to deliver accurate, safe brake service that matches your manufacturer’s recommendations.
  • Local Knowledge: Our crew understands Menasha’s driving needs, weather patterns and road conditions, so we tailor your service accordingly.

Whether it’s a squeaky brake or worn-out pads, we handle every job like it’s our own vehicle. Matthews Tire has helped Menasha drivers stay safe and confident for over 70 years.

Mechanic removing worn brake pad from disc brake assembly in Menasha, WI auto repair shop.
Google Icon
5.0 star rating

“I have been doing business here for over 20 years. I have purchased many sets of tires, had brake work and alignments done, and I am sure many other things... What great service! Hats off to Dave and the rest of the Matthews crew!”

— Rick Volkman

Because Brakes Matter Most When You Least Expect It

Your brakes are your first line of defense on the road. Whether you’re stopping at a light or reacting in an emergency, your safety, and the safety of everyone in your vehicle, depends on them working exactly as they should. At Matthews Tire, we take brake service seriously, inspecting every component and replacing worn pads with precision and care.

Schedule Your Brake Repair

Menasha Brake Pad Replacement

Warning Signs You May Need Brake Pad Replacement in Menasha

Not sure whether your brake pads are due for replacement? Keep an eye out for these indicators, it might be time to schedule a thorough brake inspection:

  • Squeaking, grinding or screeching noises when you apply pressure to the brake pedal
  • Increased stopping distance or a delay in brake responsiveness
  • Soft or spongy pedal feel underfoot when braking
  • Shuddering or vibrations through the pedal during stops
  • Dashboard brake indicator light turning on

A quick visual check can help too, if the pads are less than 1/8 inch thick (around 3–4 mm), it’s smart to replace them.

At Matthews Tire in Menasha, our certified technicians take time to evaluate your brake components and explain exactly what’s safe, what needs attention and what can wait. No pressure, just friendly, expert guidance to keep your vehicle stopping safely.

Close-up of clean disc brake and caliper assembly on vehicle in Menasha, WI auto shop.
Google Icon
5.0 star rating

“I brought my vehicle in for squeaky brakes and instead of fixing it and charging me, they actually told me that it didn't need repair! Instead of getting a few hundred bucks, they got a customer for life.”

— Paul Wisneski

Schedule Brake Pad Replacement in Menasha

When Should You Replace Brake Pads in Menasha?

Most brake pads require changing every 30,000 to 70,000 miles, though that varies with your driving habits and environment. Heavy braking, city routes and steep inclines wear pads down faster.

If you’re hearing squeaks, experiencing slower stops or notice visibly worn pads, it’s a smart time for an inspection. As a baseline: if the pad thickness drops below 1/8 inch, plan on a replacement.

At Matthews Tire in Menasha, we thoroughly assess your braking system and help you manage replacement intervals with confidence. Preventing surprises and maintaining peak safety is always our goal.

Front disc brake with surface wear and caliper exposed during service in Menasha, WI.
Google Icon
5.0 star rating

“All info was clearly explained and the final option was cost effective. No upsell or pressure to spend more than needed. Their advice was honest, cost-effective and trustworthy.”

— Katie Byrum

Protect Yourself and Your Family, Book Brake Service Now

Brake problems won’t fix themselves, and the longer you wait, the more dangerous and expensive they become. Whether you’re hearing a squeak, feeling a vibration or just due for a checkup, our team is here to help. Let Matthews Tire give you the confidence that your brakes are ready for whatever the road brings.

Book Your Brake Repair Today

Frequently Asked Brake Repair Questions

How long does brake pad replacement take at your Menasha shop?
Most brake pad replacements in Menasha take 30 minutes to 1 hour. If there are issues with the calipers or rotors, it can take up to 2 hours. Our shop is easy to reach, just minutes from downtown Menasha and close to Midway Rd, so you can drop your car off and grab lunch or run errands while we work.
Is there anything about driving in Menasha that causes faster brake wear?
Yes. Short local trips and heavy braking around busy areas, especially in downtown Menasha near the library, where traffic tends to slow and build up, can cause your brakes to wear out quicker. Stop-and-go traffic near Menasha High School and local shopping centers doesn’t help either. In addition, the Racine Street Bridge area can frequently back up due to bridge openings for boat traffic, further contributing to brake wear during extended idle and stop-start conditions.
Do you service brake pads for electric or hybrid cars in Menasha?
We do. Whether it’s a Prius, Tesla or any other hybrid, we’ve handled them for Menasha drivers. Even though regenerative braking reduces wear, these systems still rely on brake pads that eventually need replacing.
Is it a good idea to replace brake pads before winter driving in Menasha?
Definitely. Menasha roads get slick with snow and salt in the winter, and worn pads can seriously affect stopping distance. It’s especially important if you’re driving near the bridges over the Fox River or navigating icy side streets in January.
How do you know if you need brake pads replaced in Menasha’s winter conditions?
If your brakes squeak, grind or feel slow to respond, especially in snowy or icy conditions, it’s time to get them checked. In Menasha, winter salt and moisture can accelerate pad wear, so it’s smart to come in for a quick inspection before the deep freeze hits.
How close are you to Menasha neighborhoods like Neenah, Fox Crossing or Appleton for brake repair?
We’re conveniently located in Menasha, just minutes from Neenah, Fox Crossing and Appleton. Whether you’re coming from the east via Lake Park Road or from the west through downtown Neenah or Highway 441, our shop is easy to reach. We’re also close to major routes like WIS 47 and WIS 114, making it accessible for drivers throughout the Fox Cities. With nearby landmarks like Jefferson Park, downtown Menasha, and the Fox River, you’ll have plenty of ways to stay productive or unwind while we handle your brake repair.
Is your shop close to public transportation if I leave my car for brake repair?
Yes, our Menasha location is served by Valley Transit, which provides reliable service throughout the Fox Cities. Bus routes run near major roads like Appleton Road, Racine Street and downtown Menasha, making it easy to catch a ride while we work on your vehicle. Whether you’re heading to Neenah, Appleton or just running local errands, public transportation offers a convenient way to stay on the move.

Experience Auto Excellence

Never settle for subpar, overpriced auto services ever again! The ASE-certified technicians at Matthews Tire are here to bring you world-class service, dealer-level auto parts and unbeatable value on every service.

From tire installations, oil changes and alignments to full-service brake repairs, engine overhauls and more, we’ll keep you rolling.

Schedule Appointment
Happy family driving in a car together
Schedule Appointment